This sits somewhere in the middle for me. Some of the details appeal to me more than others.
There are a few things to like, but the overall impression is underwhelming. A few details keep it from feeling well considered.
This is exactly the kind of style I like. The understated look suits my taste very well. The style is a great match for my preferences.
There is a lot to like here. It would be high on my shortlist.
The presentation leaves a lot to be desired. Even allowing for personal taste, I would expect more.
Some aspects look fine, but the overall impression is mixed. A few details keep it from feeling well considered. I would keep comparing options.